Strategies to Improve Hiring Outcomes
Jul 26, 2023

As employers struggled to respond to trends such as the Great Resignation and quiet quitting, many quickly hired employees to cut costs and fill open positions. Unfortunately, reactionary hiring often didn’t work for either party. According to a USA Today poll, only 26% of job switchers liked their new position enough to stay. For this reason, many employers are shifting their focus to prioritize the quality of new hires and evaluate how their recruitment and onboarding practices can lead to more positive hiring outcomes. 


This article provides guidance on the importance of hiring outcomes and strategies employers can use to find the right employees for open positions and improve such outcomes.

Hiring Outcomes

A successful hiring outcome occurs when an employer hires the right individual for an open position. The measurements of successful hiring may vary depending on an organization’s goals and objectives. Generally, standard measures of positive hiring outcomes include employee performance, job satisfaction and organizational loyalty. A negative hiring outcome can occur when an organization hires an individual that’s ill-suited for the position or is not a good cultural fit.

The Importance of Hiring Outcomes

When the wrong person is hired, it can have numerous consequences for an organization. According to Northwestern University, a bad hiring decision can cost a company at least 30% of that employee’s annual salary. Hiring the wrong people can also reduce employee morale, damage company culture, increase employee turnover, damage employer branding and create unsafe workplaces. 


On the other hand, when an employee is a good fit for their position and organization, they’re more likely to be productive, loyal and remain with their company for longer. This ultimately benefits revenue by reducing hiring and onboarding costs and keeping knowledgeable, productive employees at the company. 

Improving Hiring Outcomes

Employers’ strategies are critical to ensuring organizations consistently hire employees that align with organizational goals. Here are strategies for employers to consider:


  • Focus on fit. A recent survey found that more than half (55%) of people lie on their resumes. Therefore, it’s crucial that employers find ways to establish a candidate’s trustworthiness. Common methods include reference checks, skills assessments and behavioral-based interviewing. Additionally, employers should pay attention to how well an individual aligns with an organization’s goals and desires, not just the qualifications listed on their resume. It may be beneficial to observe how job applicants interact with other people in the office to understand how an individual would interact with team members and contribute to company culture.
  • Be transparent. Communicate regularly and clearly with job applicants during interviews and hiring. This will improve trust and make them feel valued by an organization. Employers should also honestly describe job expectations and organizational goals to help candidates make informed decisions about job positions. Listing pay ranges alongside job postings is another way to establish trust and increase efficiency, as it reduces the risk of losing job candidates over salary expectations far along in the hiring process. In fact, workers are more likely to apply for jobs that include a pay range in the job posting, according to recent data from global employment website Monster. This can increase an employer’s talent pool and ultimately lead to better hiring outcomes.   
  • Emphasize diversity. Diversity, equity and inclusion (DE&I) is a critical element many employees consider when deciding to stay with a company. A survey by Goodhire found that 81% of employees would consider leaving their job if their employer wasn’t committed to DE&I. In addition to helping attract and retain employees, a commitment to DE&I can also improve an organization’s bottom line. According to management consulting company McKinsey, diverse and inclusive companies are 35% more likely to outperform competitors financially. 
  • Assess recruitment strategy. Recruitment methods factor into the type of candidates applying for open positions. Recent research by software company Yello found that 54% of Generation Z workers won’t complete a job application if the method is outdated. Simplifying the application process with technology like mobile-friendly applications and applicant tracking systems can help employers compete for talent. 
  • Consider temporary-to-permanent (temp-to-perm) hiring. With this type of hiring, employers hire workers on a temporary basis for a trial employment period before hiring decisions are finalized. This enables employers to fill positions without committing to permanent employment, reducing the risk of poor hiring decisions. However, employers who use this method of hiring should be aware of the potential drawbacks, such as agency fees, less committed workers and insufficient training for temporary hires. 
  • Use artificial intelligence (AI). Although a relatively new technology, AI can help evaluate and screen potential candidates. It can improve candidate experience and increase efficiency and fairness. However, employers who use AI for hiring processes should also be aware of potential accessibility issues, as it may intentionally or unintentionally screen out job seekers with disabilities. Unintentional discrimination may occur if an AI algorithm relies on historical data sets that use benchmarking resumes and other job requirements that are biased or discriminatory.

Employer Takeaway

As labor market conditions shift, employers should assess their hiring and recruiting strategies to improve positive outcomes. Employers who prioritize hiring the right person the first time may experience reduced employee turnover, improved company culture and increased revenue.


For more workplace information, contact SimcoHR today.

Sign up for our newsletter.

11 May, 2024
On April 29, 2024, the U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) Wage and Hour Division (WHD) published Field Assistance Bulletin (FAB) No. 2024-1 on the use of artificial intelligence (AI) in the workplace. The FAB follows a statement released by the White House announcing key AI-related actions following President Joe Biden’s executive order issued on Oct. 30, 2023, on establishing standards for AI safety and security. Guidance on AI-related Wage and Hour Risks Employers are increasingly using AI tools to generate timecards, set schedules, monitor performance, track employee hours and process payroll. As such, the FAB highlights certain compliance risks under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) for employers using these tools. These risks include: Tracking employee work time; Monitoring employee break and waiting time; Using location-based monitoring for individuals performing work at multiple geographic locations; Calculating employees’ regular rate of pay and overtime compensation; and Violating the FLSA’s antiretaliation provisions To aid employers in addressing these compliance risks, the WHD identifies recommended practices, including exercising proper human oversight, to help ensure that AI systems and tools do not violate the FLSA. Additional AI-related Guidance In addition to addressing FLSA compliance risks, the FAB also examines certain AI-related risks that may arise under other laws, including the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), the Providing Urgent Protections for Nursing Mothers Act (PUMP Act) and the Employee Polygraph Protection Act (EPPA). For example, using AI tools to administer FMLA leave can create potential risks for violating the law’s certification requirements when determining whether an employee’s leave is FMLA-qualifying. Employer Action Items While FABs are not necessarily legally binding, they offer insight into how the DOL interprets laws it enforces and how agency officers will analyze workplace conditions and circumstances to enforce compliance.  Using AI systems for scheduling, timekeeping and calculating rates of pay and overtime may increase an employer’s risk under the FLSA. Therefore, employers should ensure that their AI systems and tools comply with all federal laws and regulations by examining potential legal and business risks associated with AI, implementing AI usage policies and establishing internal best practices.
30 Apr, 2024
As we step into May, we're reminded of the importance of mental health and well-being. May marks Mental Health Awareness Month, offering us an opportunity to renew our commitment to nurturing our minds and fostering supportive environments, both in and out of the workplace. In this blog post, we'll explore practical strategies for enhancing mental health, including small tips that can refresh you mentally during the workday. Embracing Self-Care Amid life's hustle and bustle, it's crucial to carve out time for self-care. Whether it's practicing mindfulness, engaging in hobbies, or simply taking a moment to breathe deeply, prioritizing self-care nurtures mental resilience and fosters a sense of inner peace. Cultivating Work-Life Balance In today's fast-paced world, achieving a healthy work-life balance is essential for mental well-being. Set boundaries between work and personal life, establish a routine that includes breaks and leisure activities, and strive to unplug from technology during downtime. Remember, balance is key to sustaining productivity and happiness. Fostering a Supportive Workplace Culture Employers play a pivotal role in promoting mental health in the workplace. Encourage open dialogue about mental health, offer resources such as counseling services or mental health days, and prioritize flexibility to accommodate employees' well-being needs. By fostering a supportive culture, organizations cultivate environments where employees feel valued, understood, and empowered to prioritize their mental health. Supporting Loved Ones If someone you care about is struggling with mental health challenges, your support can make a significant difference. Listen without judgment, offer empathy and reassurance, and encourage them to seek professional help if needed. Remember, your presence and understanding can provide comfort and strength during difficult times. Practicing Gratitude Gratitude is a powerful tool for enhancing mental well-being. Take time each day to reflect on moments of gratitude, whether it's appreciating the beauty of nature, expressing gratitude for supportive relationships, or acknowledging personal achievements. Cultivating a mindset of gratitude fosters resilience and enhances overall happiness. Small Tips to Refresh Your Mind During the Workday  Take short breaks: Step away from your desk for a few minutes to stretch, walk around, or simply gaze out the window. These brief pauses can rejuvenate your mind and boost productivity. Practice deep breathing: Incorporate deep breathing exercises into your day to reduce stress and promote relaxation. Close your eyes, inhale deeply through your nose, hold for a few seconds, and exhale slowly through your mouth. Connect with nature: Spend time outdoors during your lunch break or coffee breaks. Even a brief stroll in a nearby park or green space can invigorate your senses and clear your mind. Listen to music: Create a playlist of soothing music or uplifting tunes to listen to during work breaks. Music has the power to uplift your mood, reduce anxiety, and enhance focus. Stay hydrated: Drink plenty of water throughout the day to stay hydrated and maintain mental alertness. Dehydration can impair cognitive function, so keep a water bottle handy and sip regularly. Practice mindfulness: Take a few moments to practice mindfulness or meditation exercises. Focus on your breath, observe your thoughts without judgment, and cultivate a sense of presence and calm. Declutter your workspace: A clutter-free workspace can promote mental clarity and productivity. Take a few minutes to tidy up your desk, organize files, and create a calming environment conducive to focus. Engage in positive self-talk: Replace negative self-talk with affirming and encouraging statements. Remind yourself of your strengths, accomplishments, and capabilities, and cultivate a mindset of self-compassion and resilience. Connect with colleagues: Build supportive relationships with coworkers by engaging in meaningful conversations, sharing experiences, and offering mutual support. A sense of camaraderie and connection can foster a positive work environment and bolster mental well-being. As Mental Health Awareness Month unfolds, let's commit to nurturing our minds and supporting those around us. By embracing self-care, fostering work-life balance, promoting workplace well-being, and offering compassionate support to loved ones, we contribute to a culture of mental health awareness and resilience. Remember, you are not alone. Reach out for support if you need it, and let's journey toward better mental health together.
30 Apr, 2024
On April 23, 2024, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) announced a final rule to amend current requirements employees in white-collar occupations must satisfy to qualify for an overtime exemption under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The final rule will take effect on July 1, 2024. Increased Salary Level The FLSA white-collar exemptions apply to individuals in executive, administrative, professional, and some outside sales and computer-related occupations. Some highly compensated employees may also qualify for the FLSA white-collar overtime exemption. To qualify for this exemption, white-collar employees must satisfy the standard salary level test, among other criteria. This salary level is a wage threshold that white-collar employees must receive to qualify for the exemption. Starting July 1, 2024, the DOL’s final rule increases the standard salary level from: $684 to $844 per week ($35,568 to $43,888 per year); and $107,432 to $132,964 per year for highly compensated employees. On Jan. 1, 2025, the standard salary level will then increase from: $844 to $1,128 per week ($43,888 to $58,656 per year); and $132,964 to $151,164 per year for highly compensated employees. Automatic Updates The DOL’s final rule also includes mechanisms allowing the agency to automatically update the white-collar salary level thresholds without having to rely on the rulemaking process. Effective July 1, 2027, and every three years thereafter, the DOL will increase the standard salary level. The agency will apply up-to-date wage data to determine new salary levels. Impact on Employers The first salary level increase in July is expected to impact nearly 1 million workers, while the second increase in January is expected to affect approximately 3 million workers. Employers should become familiar with the final rule and evaluate what changes they may need to adopt to comply with the rule’s requirements. Legal challenges to the rule are anticipated, which may delay the final rule’s implementation.

Have a question? Get in touch.

Share by: